I haven’t yet gushed about the arrival of October. I am thrilled that it’s here and hoping for more seasonal temperatures in the next few weeks. This last week has been much warmer than typical October weather (in the 80s) and I’m ready to say goodbye to summer. But we can definitely see the leaves changing and the days getting shorter, so I know the cooler weather is on its way.
I’m “late” with this post again – I’m running late with almost everything lately! (I’m working hard to adjust my expectations to my current life.) But I’m very excited to share this week’s reading with you. It’s an eccentric list: one buzzy new book, one title published in the 1940s, and three chapter book readalouds. Let the October reading begin!
I read Brideshead Revisited because it’s believed that The Secret History is the American version of this book. I can see the parallels – a middle class person observing the habits and daily life of the extraordinarily wealthy, but I can say that Donna Tartt took her version to an extreme that this one never reached.
This is book is set mostly in the 1920s and is about Charles Ryder, a young man at Oxford who befriends Sebastian Flyte, a wealthy man who feels stifled by his family. We follow the Flyte family drama through Ryder’s eyes. Despite all of Sebastian’s foibles, he was the most likable character in the whole book and I found Charles to be completely unlikable. Their relationship is ambiguous; I assumed it was sexual but the author never said so directly, which is exactly how it would have been in the 1920s.
This book was enjoyable but I wish there were more scenes at Oxford. I’d love recommendations for books set at Oxford and Cambridge, if you have them!

The Vaster Wilds is Lauren Groff’s newest effort and it was a strange little book! It’s the story of a young girl who escapes a colonial settlement after enduring a lifetime of abuse. She desperately wants to live and goes through the most excruciating circumstances to do so. While trekking through the forest – to where? – she grapples with her religious beliefs in ways that I could relate.
I struggled with how to rate this book on Goodreads because my feelings contradicted themselves. I found the writing to be comforting and lulling, despite the terror and desperation infused into every sentence. And it felt like Groff squeezed her most closely held confusions onto the page. And still — this journey was excruciating and never really crescendoed for me. Does that make sense? I decided on 4 stars.
Mary Bowser and the Civil War Spy Ring was so much fun! This little novel was based on a true story: Mary Bowser was a Union spy during the Civil War and infiltrated the Confederate White House. She pretended to be a not-very-smart maid but, thank to her photographic memory, passed along information on almost every document that moved across Jefferson Davis’s desk. This book tells young readers her story and gives them a puzzle to solve. At the end, Mary had to leave her post quickly in order to save her life but she left her precious journal behind. She leaves the reader clues about where to find it. The book includes a spycraft kit to help solve that mystery.
Bryce adored this book. He was entranced by every word and every picture, seeking out clues to the mystery. There are a couple more of these books on his history curriculum and I’m looking forward to getting to them!


Thanks to our timing, Bronwyn and I finished two Molly books in the last week. Molly’s Surprise was her Christmas book. Her family is trying to get excited about Christmas, but they still haven’t heard from her father who is serving as a doctor in England during WWII. They’re not so interested in getting gifts from him but they desperately want to know that he’s okay. Will they receive word from him in time to be able to enjoy Christmas Day?
And we met a new friend in Happy Birthday, Molly. Emily is an English girl sent to stay with her aunt in the states in order to stay safe during the war. She stays with Molly’s family for a bit while her aunt recovers from pneumonia. Emily is reserved and nervous about being in a new place and frightened about what’s happening to her family back home, so she is slow to warm to Molly and her friends. Molly learned a lot about respecting other people’s feelings and understanding how our trauma in our pasts can affect the way we act. This one might be my favorite Molly book so far.
I have a confession: I wish Molly was Jewish. I think the American Girl series had an opportunity to explore American Jewish life during WWII with Molly!
I think this is the last post I’ll be able to publish this week! I’m planning to be back on Monday with an update on my October decluttering challenge. Whatever your weekend holds, I hope it’s full of exactly what you need. Take good care!



I think of your posts to be right on time whenever I find one in my email box!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, Juliann!!
LikeLike
I know others have read The Vaster Wilds and panned it, but I’m still interested to read it and decide for myself — it’s the “weird little books” that I find I often keep thinking about long after I’ve finished them!
Molly the American Girl may not be Jewish, but there is a Jewish one! Her name is Rebecca and she’s in the WWI era. Looks like there are books!
LikeLike
Thanks for the tip on Rebecca! We’ve only been reading the original girls but now I’m realizing that I’ve been missing out on interesting stories. And it looks like my library has some of the Rebecca books, so we’ll move on to her after Molly.
And I think Vaster Wilds is totally worth trying. It’s so hard for me to describe. On one hand — I was a little bored and wanted to know what the point was. Luckily, the book is short. On the other hand — I still loved her journey and found her desperation to live, despite not knowing what her life would be like or where she was going, inspiring. I was especially moved by specific passages that we can discuss after you’ve read the book (I wrote them down before I returned the book). Her revelations about nature and religion hit the right spot for me.
Groff certainly writes books that are discussable!
LikeLike
Lauren Groff (used to be?) one of my favorite authors. I loved everything she wrote up until Matrix, which I couldn’t finish. I hear that The Vaster Wilds is the same. Authors certainly have the write to change their writing style, but personally it’s a bummer! The last Oxford book I remember reading was The Madwoman Upstairs, but that’s a little lighter of a read so I’m not sure if it would be your thing.
LikeLike
Ha! I wrote “write” instead of “right”!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I listened to Matrix on audio and struggled with it, but liked it overall. But I know what you mean — it was a difficult one. Other than Vaster Wilds and Matrix, the only other book by her that I’ve read was her debut, The Monsters of Templeton, which I loved!
Thank you for the Oxford recommendation! I’ve read that one and really enjoyed it, so it’s a perfect rec. I think I’m going to reread the first book in the Discovery of Witches series this year because I loved it SO much when it first came out. It’s Oxford setting is pure perfection!
LikeLike
I hope you’re getting more comfortable posting when you have time and something to share. Schedules are good for other things! AND your books – I will read Vaster Wilds this month – so interesting that the reviews in our FM community are “varied” … and Brideshead Revisited is a lifetime favorite I haven’t re-read in over 10 years. I picked up The Trio (featured in Sara’s Fall Compendium) and the cover copy says it’s Sally Rooney meets Brideshead Revisited. That makes me excited to read it AND Brideshead!
LikeLike
I am NOT getting more comfortable with it 😂 I like being consistent and dependable and this willy nilly posting style doesn’t work for my personality! But I’m trying.
I can’t wait to hear what you think about Vaster Wilds. It was a tough one for me but I enjoyed it overall. How fun to have a Brideshead-esque book in your queue! I picked up The Starling House from the library yesterday and will be starting after I finished my current read (The Hundred-Year House. So good!). I can’t wait!
LikeLike
I remember watching Brideshead Revisited on PBS WAY back in the day. A gorgeously done series, well worth finding if you ever were so inclined. That and The Forsythe Saga were my first experiences of mini-series addiction!
LikeLike
Thank you for that tip! And how funny – I just took the Forsythe Saga from freebie shelf at the library. My librarian said she loved both Brideshead and TFS –and it just happened to be up for the taking!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well you could try the Morse books set in Oxford in the 1970s by Colin Dexter. Maybe I should go and take some photos of Oxford for a post. I met my husband in Cambridge and keep thinking about a trip back
LikeLike
Thank you for the book recommendation! Those look fabulous. And I love that you and your husband met at Cambridge – how romantic!
LikeLike
I never give a thought to the date and time of posts but enjoy them whenever they are written. Sometimes, many times in fact, I’m late to read and comment. As for a book set in Oxford, The Dictionary of Lost Words mostly takes place in Oxford. It’s a little lighter historical fiction but I really enjoyed it.
LikeLike
The Dictionary of Lost Words looks so good – thank you for the recommendation! I am also always late to read/respond to blogs. I figure later is better than never, right?!
LikeLike
I’m glad you liked Vaster Wilds – I just loved it but perhaps it was enhanced by my seeing her talk about it in person right before I read it!
I hope you get some cooler weather – it was ridiculously warm here too until yesterday.
LikeLike
Those connections with authors are so wonderful! I’m still jealous that you got to see her in person — it sounded like a fascinating author talk! The weather has definitely cooled down this weekend, phew! I’m glad you’re also getting some relief.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey Katie,
I think you will like the All Souls trilogy. It has witches, vampires, science and magic. And, it’s set in Oxford/Cambridge.
Please read them and let me know if you liked it.
LikeLike
That is the PERFECT recommendation – thank you! I read the series a long time ago and it’s absolutely worth revisiting. I love Diana Bishop and her tea addiction, also: all the time in the Bodleian library!
LikeLiked by 1 person